Nominal and absolute
Every cartridge carries a micron number. What that number promises depends on the word in front of it, and on the test that produced it. Two cartridges both sold as 1 µm can behave very differently in the same line.
Nominal ratings
A nominal rating says that the cartridge removes a stated share of particles at that size. It is the normal basis for string wound, depth and most pre-filter pleats, where the job is to hold dirt, not to guarantee a cut-off.
Absolute ratings
An absolute rating says that particles or organisms at that size are retained under defined test conditions. It is the basis for final and sterile membranes, where a single pass has to be reliable and the result has to be provable.
Every Gopani membrane page states the retention basis, or says on request. How we state retention
The test behind the number
Read this section if you are comparing a datasheet from one supplier with a datasheet from another.
Particle challenge
Most nominal and many absolute ratings come from a particle challenge: a known test dust or bead suspension is passed through the cartridge and counted before and after. Three details decide what the number means:
- The efficiency quoted. A rating at 90 percent and a rating at 99.9 percent are different cartridges.
- The test fluid and flow. Ratings measured at low flow in water can read tighter than the same cartridge in your process.
- When the count was taken. Efficiency often rises as a depth cartridge loads, so an initial figure and an average figure differ.
Bacterial challenge
Sterile-grade membranes are rated against a bacterial challenge at a defined concentration, and the cartridge is integrity tested so the same result can be confirmed in the plant. The integrity test is what links the rating on the datasheet to the cartridge in your housing.
Why the same micron filters differently
A rating describes a cut point. It does not describe the structure that produces it. A membrane captures at its surface; a wound or depth cartridge captures through its wall; a sintered element captures in a metal pore network that can be cleaned and used again.
Catalogue ranges. A bar shows where a family is offered, not how it performs at each rating.
That is why a like-for-like replacement is a question of structure and basis first, and micron second. A 1 µm nominal wound cartridge and a 1 µm absolute membrane are not substitutes, even though the number matches.
Questions to ask before you compare
- Nominal or absolute? If the datasheet does not say, ask before anything else.
- At what efficiency, and measured how? The percentage, the challenge and the test conditions.
- Surface or depth? It decides whether the cartridge is there to hold dirt or to guarantee a cut-off.
- When is it changed? Dirt holding and the recommended change-out pressure set the interval.
Clarypleat PES is Gopani's PES membrane cartridge, rated to ASTM F838 and integrity tested as described above. See the product
Related reading
- My membranes blind in weeks, not monthsField problem, pleated cartridges
- Sizing a pre-filter on dirt loadKnowledge, filtration trains
- Reading a differential pressure logKnowledge, change-out
Related products
- Clarypleat PESSterile filtration
- Clarywound Extreme BicoViscous fluids, up to 120 °C
- Clarysynt powder sintered0.5 to 200 µm, cleanable